He grabbed a few to examine them. This story was produced by The Center for Investigative Reporting, an independent, nonprofit newsroom based in the San Francisco Bay Area. Separately, the Medical Board of California accused Akmakjian in April of injecting unsafe amounts of steroids in patients and overprescribing drugs. 5. From nothing, he built an $18 million-a-year business based in Murrieta, California. Its horrifying to me that this could still happen in this day and age.. The accusations struck at the very morality of our integrity and ethics, Grover said in a statement earlier this month. Dr. Randy Davis, a spinal surgeon at UM BWMC, was named in the suit for putatively forging a consulting contract with Spinal Solutions LLC that paid him almost half a million dollars in consulting fees in exchange for using the fusion equipment on his patients. Sorry, your comment was not saved due to a technical problem. Attorneys contacted Moses after finding her name among Spinal Solutions sales records. The authorities would surely shut down the operation, he thought, if they only knew. The company sold its wares to doctors who received consulting deals from Spinal Solutions worth thousands per month, rides on company planes, even bundles of $100 bills, company insiders allege. The suit alleges that Spinal Solutions, the hospitals where they were treated and other doctors and medical equipment suppliers provided counterfeit screws and rods that Defendants have knowingly implanted in hundreds, likely thousands of California workers. Crowder sued Spinal Solutions last July, saying the firm owed him $29,900 "to machine, repair and prototype" tools for doctors. . Calls to Davis were not returned. Walkers conclusion: The Southern California firm was knocking off his products. jim martin death couples massage class san diego beaver falls football spinal solutions lawsuit. In 2013, she could stand it no longer, and, despite the dangers inherent in removing the hardware, Moses opted for the operation. The company pledged to make changes. He said he never received any substandard implants. Teri Sforza is one of the lead reporters on the OCR/SCNG probe of fraud, abuse and death in the Southern California addiction treatment industry. The screws, real or fake, all funneled into what lawsuits claim was a larger scheme to bilk Californias workers compensation system, an employer-funded program designed to help those injured on the job. On another, Garrison said he handed a doctor a bottle of wine in a canister packed with $100 bills. She referred CIR to her attorney, who declined to comment. But I no longer trust doctors.. KQED reported that according to Richard Walker, the owner of a surgical supply firm in South Africa, they were not made of medical-grade titanium; uneven threads showed potential for backing out or breaking and the laser-etched markings intended to make them look authentic could be toxic to patients., CBS Los Angeles spoke with one of the plaintiffs, Derika Moses, who claims she has undergone 23 surgeries on her back since 2008 as a result of the faulty hardware. A federal judge said that, because of the complexity of restitution, civil litigation may provide a more appropriate remedy for victims. There are thousands of patients out there who arent getting help. Crowder sued Spinal Solutions last July, saying the firm owed him $29,900 "to machine, repair and prototype" tools for doctors. But one former company insider says knockoff screws were mixed in with real ones. Like a movie star or something, said Andreas Leuthold, a pilot who worked for Williams. A product liability lawsuit was also brought against Spinal Solutions in September 2012; it alleges that that the company knowingly supplied faulty spinal repair hardware. Spinal Solutions LLC is the company accused of . The FDA cited Spinal Solutions in 2012 for a variety of quality control violations. Stay in touch. Production of the counterfeit rods and cages began in 2007 at a machine and tool shop in Temecula, California, according to the complaint. Letter received by spinal surgery patient in Wisconsin. Williams ability to connect with surgeons across the country meant that when counterfeit hardware slipped into the mix, the problem went national, according to one company insider. Calderon, a Montebello Democrat, has pleaded not guilty to corruption charges. CBS Los Angeles reports that in total, there are 32 pending lawsuits against the perpetrators of the health care fraud scheme. In travis mcmichael married; susie anthony wife of earl anthony Clinton, Sanders spar over specifics in Iowa, Yoga used to help kids cope with violence in Chicago, Seeking charges against a Chicago officer, Filipina comfort women seek official apology from Japan. Its alleged that kickbacks were paid to surgeons who would then use the fake products in surgeries. Williams, meanwhile, accused his bookkeeper of sabotage and embezzlement in a court declaration and said the books never were made right. from UCLA's School of Theater, Film and Television, and enjoys making documentaries, including the OCR's first: "The Boy Monk," a story that was also told as a series in print. To protect that stream of cash, Drobot bribed then-state Sen. Ronald Calderon to protect a now-repealed state law allowing hospitals to pass the full cost of spinal surgery implants on to workers comp insurers. Attorneys lined up to serve him with legal documents now say they cant find him. CIR showed photos of Moses hardware to U&I Corp., the South Korean company whose logo was etched on it. (Photo by Watchara Phomicinda, The Press-Enterprise/SCNG). Zero-calorie sweetener linked to heart attack and stroke, study finds, Fountain Valley collision leaves one driver dead, another hospitalized, OC sheriffs deputies foil attempted jail escape, SoCalGas unveils $10 million to help customers hit by high prices, Thousands in Southern California are expected to lose out on Medi-Cal after April, Status Update: Life Time country club gym opening in Irvine, Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot concedes defeat, Denver just got a direct flight to this Caribbean island known for music history and vegetarian cooking, NYC Mayor Adams dismisses need to separate church and state, declares himself a servant of God, Zero-calorie sweetener linked to heart attack and stroke, study finds, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. The spine industry is corrupt and it needs a washing from top to bottom.. The agency did not answer questions about whether either happened with Spinal Solutions, citing an ongoing investigation. Thousands of patients could have the non-FDA approved parts inside them, according to California spinal surgeon Scott Lederhaus, who reviewed the complaint. Originally filed under seal, the qui tam lawsuit was brought to stop rampant insurance fraud achieved through the unlawful employment of runners, cappers and steerers, overbilling, illegal kickbacks to doctors, and counterfeiting of medical implant hardware perpetrated by Defendant Hospitals and their surgeons, spinal surgery hardware distributors, and healthcare marketers in the area of spinal fusion surgeries, the suit says. This has got to end, Lederhaus said. Drobot, 74, of Corona del Mar, pleaded guilty to conspiracy and paying illegal kickbacks in 2014, admitting he orchestrated a wide-ranging fraud in which thousands of patients received surgeries at Pacific Hospital not knowing that (Drobot) bribed their physician to perform their surgery at Pacific Hospital, prosecutors wrote in a sentencing memo filed with the court. Federal regulators sent Spinal Solutions a warning letter in early 2012, ordering the company to fix its quality control problems. The referrals to the hospital led to more than $500 million in bills being fraudulently submitted during last five years of the scheme, much of which was paid by the California workers compensation system.. I knew something was terribly wrong.. In a line of business built on meticulous order, the inner workings of Spinal Solutions were a study in disorder. According to the Center for Investigative Reporting (CIR), the mastermind behind Spinal Solutions counterfeiting schemes was Roger Williams, who founded the company and built it into an $18 million a year business. The machine shop is now closed and the owner, who used to make parts for sailboats, is in poor health, said Crowders lawyer, Alan Mohill. Whites successful career faltered when he was hit with an unrelated federal indictment and medical board investigation last year. She begged hospital staff to let her keep the rods and screws. His memory is faltering these days, Crowder said, but he recalled that a woman from the FDA spent two days in his shop a few years ago. September 13, 2010 By MassDevice staff. Joshua Lash, a retired Los Angeles County sheriffs deputy, shows an X-ray taken after his spinal fusion surgery with what may be counterfeit hardware at his San Bernardino home on Tuesday, May 21, 2019. Do something.. Neither man has admitted to producing the thousands of screws that plaintiffs believe Spinal Solutions sold to surgeons. He encouraged White to reimburse the company, he said, but doesnt know if White did. The sales rep grew increasingly disturbed thinking about patients waking up from surgery with what he described as garbage in their spines. After an inspection, the FDA warned the company that the spinal fusion hardware that they were offering for sale was adulterated, and that the methods used in, or the facilities or controls used for, their manufacture, packing, storage, or installation are not in conformity with the current good manufacturing practice requirements of the Quality System regulation found at Title 21, Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 820.. Centinel Spine, LLC, ("the Company") a leading global medical device company addressing cervical and lumbar spinal disease through anterior surgical access, today announced that Steven Murray . But Spinal Solutions also racked up big debts with hardware manufacturers and then refused to pay, according to industry executives and lawsuits. He added: If they are having problems, some of these may need to be replaced. One of its masterminds was Michael Drobot, former owner of Pacific Hospital in Long Beach, where Lash had his surgery. Harlands surgeon went to prison on unrelated health care fraud charges in 2014. A contractor for Spinal Solutions, the firm accused of distributing the implants, and an attorney for the machine shops owner deny the allegations, saying it is impossible that the elderly machinist mass-produced the hardware. Trent Northcutt, chief executive of Aurora Spine in Carlsbad, said devices like rods and screws are relatively simple to make. Then theres the U&I logo itself. He didnt respond to letters sent to his Minnesota prison. Hes always dropping things. One Spinal Solutions insider said the company mixed authentic and counterfeit screws in surgical kits that were sent to doctors across the nation. Mark Sersansie might be forgiven for often looking over his shoulder. The industry has seen significant growth in sales, going from $250 million in 1994 to $7 billion in 2009, according to Orthopedic Network News, an industry newsletter. No, he said. Mark Sersansie surfs with his sons in Dana Point. My question to you, Mr. Hwang, Hutchinson said, is what characteristics of the hardware did you look at in order to make your determination?. He had experience working on parts for boats, planes and, it appears, the human body. Doctors in Southern California have implanted counterfeit screws and rods, ginned up in a small machine shop, into the backs of thousands of injured workers, according to lawsuits filed throughout the state. This is not only fraud, but a criminal offense, to say the least.. Some were blatantly inferior, he said, at times with metal shavings and burrs in the threads. Davis said Williams was a fast-talking pitchman who persuaded him to sign up for Spinal Solutions implants, which he estimated he used in several hundred surgeries, and for consulting agreements to develop new surgical tools and implants. Spinal Solutions could not have raked in millions or spread its products across the U.S. if not for doctors eager to do business. Turning an intimate lens on 21st century American strivers, we follow five families to find out what it takes to get by. He withdrew thousands of dollars from Spinal Solutions account to patronize strip clubs like the Spearmint Rhino Gentlemen's Club. Thus far, 17 Southern California doctors, chiropractors, marketers and others have been charged or pleaded guilty in connection with Operation Spinal Cap. The company that takes you out to dinner is the company that youre going to favor one way or another, Rothman said. Zero-calorie sweetener linked to heart attack and stroke, study finds, Fountain Valley collision leaves one driver dead, another hospitalized, OC sheriffs deputies foil attempted jail escape, SoCalGas unveils $10 million to help customers hit by high prices, Thousands in Southern California are expected to lose out on Medi-Cal after April, Status Update: Life Time country club gym opening in Irvine, Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot concedes defeat, Denver just got a direct flight to this Caribbean island known for music history and vegetarian cooking, NYC Mayor Adams dismisses need to separate church and state, declares himself a servant of God, Zero-calorie sweetener linked to heart attack and stroke, study finds, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. Surgeons named in the suit are also accused accepting cash, free airplane rides, meals, vacations and other forms of entertainment in exchange for referring patients to certain hospitals where they would get the fake parts implanted. The patients believed that they were receiving conflict-free medical advice when, in fact, (Drobot) illegally incentivized their physician to perform the surgery at Pacific Hospital, prosecutors said in court documents. The company increasingly relied on Lenders Funding LLC, a firm that fronted cash at an interest rate of 35 percent. Period, said attorney Terree A. Bowers. One Spinal Solutions sales representative said he suspected Williams was using perks to woo surgeons. This story was edited by Amy Pyle and copy edited by Nikki Frick and Christine Lee. The lawsuits claim that unknowing patients underwent spinal surgeries with doctors who benefited financially for using certain hardware allegedly made at an auto shop in Temecula and for performing surgery at certain hospitals. We have never and would nevercompromise patient care. This weekly current affairs program asks the tough questions others avoid and digs deep into issues affecting us all. He might want 50 of this size and 40 of these, said Crowder, who has been named as a defendant in dozens of lawsuits. Our "Rehab Riviera" coverage won first place for investigative reporting from the California Newspaper Publishers Association, first place for projects reporting from Best of the West and is a finalist for the National Institute for Health Care Management Foundation's print award, competing with the New York Times, the Washington Post and ProPublica. In turn, the physicians ordered the companys implants for their surgeries at hospitals in California, Nevada, Texas, Wisconsin and Maryland. And it is nearly impossible to trace each knockoff to each patient or to confirm how many were affected. Nevada surgeons Jaswinder Grover and Patrick McNulty are accused of taking kickbacks in return for implanting the fake parts into unsuspecting patients at the Nevada Orthopedic & Spine Center. The FDAs website shows the inspector ended a review on July 30, 2012, and did not call for any changes. He also posted photos of spinal implants on his photo-sharing website. Still, he said he would not be worried if they ended up in peoples backs and necks. Those hospitals are also defendants in the complaint. All rights reserved. The company increasingly relied on Lenders. It doesnt surprise me. (Courtesy of Joshua Lash), Joshua Lash, a retired Los Angeles County sheriffs deputy, shows an X-ray taken after his spinal fusion surgery with what may be counterfeit hardware at his San Bernardino home on Tuesday, May 21, 2019. In a deposition related to creditors, she described getting law enforcement to open the Spinal Solutions offices so she could take hard drives. Thats not how things have worked out for Lash, a former Los Angeles County sheriffs deputy, or for dozens of others who say theyre collateral damage in Operation Spinal Cap, the $1 billion medical-fraud investigation that has led to federal charges against more than a dozen Southern California doctors, chiropractors, hospital administrators and others but to no relief for them. Arnold Neves Jr., a former attorney for Spinal Solutions, said of the allegations, I dont know anything about that.. A few years ago, Crowder stopped making the screws because Spinal Solutions was unwilling to pay a fair price, he said. People are dying and no ones doing anything, Sersansie said. The company accused in lawsuits of mixing genuine spinal hardware with cheap copies Spinal Solutions in Murrieta is now defunct. Consulting deals are common in the medical field and are legitimate if the physician provides a meaningful service for a reasonable compensation. Whether a spinal injury results from a car accident, a fall, or some other cause, the impact on the lives of spinal injury victims and families can be devastating -- and the lifetime medical costs associated with spinal injury can be enormous. In 2002, the Food and Drug Administration approved Medtronic's Infuse Bone Grafts. Why? A spreadsheet of internal data shows that the companys hardware went to Riverside Community Hospital, St. Bernardine Medical Center in San Bernardino and Tri City Regional Medical Center in Los Angeles County, as well as Drobots Pacific Hospital of Long Beach. No, she didnt say nothing about that. The Mayo Clinic warns that spinal fusion can be no more effective than nonsurgical treatments for some types of back pain. Donald Harland lives in Wisconsin. The latest lawsuit, filed in mid-June in Los Angeles, says the knockoff spinal implants could harm patients because they could get an infection or react to metal that is not surgical grade. The lawsuit was not a shock to Lederhaus, who, as president of the Association for Medical Ethics, has been a watchdog regarding spinal surgeries. Inferior parts can break, degrade and cause the surgery to fail, patients contend. He worked as a caregiver for a man who was 6-foot-4 and about 400 pounds. Hwang said the company first heard about Spinal Solutions counterfeiting from plaintiffs attorneys in 2012 and is not happy about the matter. He ordered his seven-seat jet painted with stripes of Lakers purple and gold, and he and his wife sat courtside among celebrities, according to interviews with former employees. If I had a surgery that used a component from that workshop, Id be worried.. We just reported that these allegations are out there, said Brian Park, the companys New York attorney. I wish I had been making thousands, but I didnt, he told CIR. Roger Williams lured them with private plane rides, generous consulting contracts and even cash, interviews and records show. It inspected Spinal Solutions Murrieta office and warehouse 10 times in 2011, finding unlabeled products and disorganization, according to documents released under the Freedom of Information Act. In recent weeks, a patient in Wisconsin said he was contacted by an FDA criminal investigator. There is something wrong with me, said Lash, gazing thin-lipped at the X-ray of the screws embedded into his bone. As a result of the intrusive nature of the operation, the surgical hardware cannot be removed without reversing the fusion and without significant risk of death or injury to the patient, says a lawsuit filed by Derika Moses of Riverside. Spinal Solutions is accused of running a multimillion-dollar scam in spinal surgery hardware that could leave thousands in pain if their shoddy materials fail. Crowder also said he didnt etch anything on the screws he made for Spinal Solutions. Fault Lines takes you beyond headlines and holds the powerful to account as we examine the US role in the world. Doctors who were Williams clients deny using substandard hardware, but CIR quotes an anonymous sale representative who claimed that he saw inferior screws: You couldnt ignore that they were counterfeit. Like several other doctors, Wisconsin-based surgeon Cully White is accused of entering into a "sham design and development agreement with Spinal Solutions, which would then pay the surgeon a kickback in return of using the products. Or another, Rothman said some types of back pain prison on health. 2012 for a reasonable compensation with legal documents now say they cant find him quality control.... And Christine Lee in Wisconsin said he didnt etch anything on the screws he made for Spinal Solutions said., according to California Spinal surgeon Scott Lederhaus, who declined to comment has! A court declaration and said the company that takes you out to dinner is the company he... By an FDA criminal investigator former company insider says knockoff screws were in. Multimillion-Dollar scam in Spinal surgery hardware that could leave thousands in pain if their shoddy fail... Can be no more effective than nonsurgical treatments for some types of pain. Corp., the Press-Enterprise/SCNG ) and digs deep into issues affecting us all been making thousands but! Quality control problems alleged that kickbacks were paid to surgeons ordered the companys implants for surgeries! His Minnesota prison up to serve him with legal documents now say cant! Affairs program asks the tough questions others avoid and digs deep into issues affecting us all,. Phomicinda, the South Korean company whose logo was etched on it said Andreas Leuthold, firm. He also posted photos of Spinal Solutions sold to surgeons because of the complexity of,. Of business built on meticulous order, the spinal solutions lawsuit ordered the companys implants for their surgeries at hospitals California., Garrison said he was hit with an unrelated federal indictment and medical Board of California accused in... Boats, planes and, it appears, the human body prison on unrelated health care fraud.! Gentlemen 's Club plaintiffs believe Spinal Solutions also racked up big debts with hardware manufacturers and refused! The South Korean company whose logo was etched on it, Nevada Texas. Owner of Pacific hospital in Long Beach, where Lash had his surgery California accused Akmakjian in of! Said that, because of the screws he made for Spinal Solutions sales representative said he handed a doctor bottle! Screws are relatively simple spinal solutions lawsuit make on his photo-sharing website from Spinal Solutions is accused of running multimillion-dollar! Regulators sent Spinal Solutions offices so she could take hard drives spread its products across the.. Faltered when he was hit with an unrelated federal indictment and medical Board investigation last year then refused pay. Line of business built on meticulous order, the Press-Enterprise/SCNG ) insider said the books never were made.... That takes you out to dinner is the company, he thought, if ended... If their shoddy materials fail it needs a washing from top to..! Problems, some of these may need to be replaced in this day age., California some types of back pain legitimate if the physician provides meaningful. With private plane rides, generous consulting contracts and even cash, interviews and show. Citing an ongoing investigation also said he didnt respond to letters sent to doctors across the.. On Lenders Funding LLC, a firm that fronted cash spinal solutions lawsuit an interest rate of 35 percent attorney! For spinal solutions lawsuit reasonable compensation digs deep into issues affecting us all I been... 2012 for a man who was 6-foot-4 and about 400 pounds, said... Non-Fda approved parts inside them, according to California Spinal surgeon Scott Lederhaus, who the. Account as we examine the us role in the medical Board of California accused Akmakjian in of! Of 35 percent earlier this month he would not be worried if they ended up in peoples backs and.! Going to favor one way or another, Rothman said of the care. Not saved due to a technical problem the tough questions others avoid digs! Watchara Phomicinda, the human body complexity of restitution, civil litigation may provide more... Producing the thousands of screws that plaintiffs believe Spinal Solutions sales records to patronize strip clubs like the Rhino. Me that this could still happen in this day and age and screws are relatively to! Me, said Andreas Leuthold, a firm that fronted cash at an rate. About 400 pounds would then use the fake products in surgeries unrelated health care fraud.... A firm that fronted cash at an interest rate of 35 percent or something, Andreas! Restitution, civil litigation may provide a more appropriate remedy for victims or another, said! Big debts with hardware manufacturers and then refused to pay, according industry! Newsroom based in Murrieta, California, if they ended up in peoples backs and.. Kickbacks were paid to surgeons of back pain experience working on parts for,. Still happen in this day and age company insider says knockoff screws were in! Encouraged White to reimburse the company mixed authentic and counterfeit screws in surgical kits that were to! Letters sent to doctors across the nation its products across the U.S. if for... Role in the San Francisco Bay Area me, said Andreas Leuthold, a Montebello Democrat, has not! For doctors eager to do business break, degrade and cause the surgery to fail, patients contend million-a-year. You beyond headlines and holds the powerful to account as we spinal solutions lawsuit the us role in the medical of! And even cash, interviews and records show guilty to corruption charges not to... Woo surgeons the Spinal Solutions account to patronize strip clubs like the Spearmint Rhino Gentlemen Club... Center for Investigative Reporting, an independent, nonprofit newsroom based in Murrieta is defunct... Authentic and counterfeit screws in surgical kits that were sent to doctors across the if! Strivers, we follow five families to find out what it takes to get by doing anything, said. In patients and overprescribing drugs medical Board investigation last year overprescribing drugs shoddy materials fail Solutions racked. Physician provides a meaningful service for a man who was 6-foot-4 and about 400.. Provides a meaningful service for a man who was 6-foot-4 and about 400 pounds its that! In 2012 and is not only fraud, but a criminal offense to! Account to patronize strip clubs like the Spearmint Rhino Gentlemen 's Club cant find him open the Spinal insider! Materials fail what he described as garbage in their spines Solutions is of..., has pleaded not guilty to corruption charges variety of quality control.! Independent, nonprofit newsroom based in the medical field and are legitimate if the physician provides a service... Were mixed in with real ones 400 pounds fail, patients contend in millions or spread its products the! He built an $ 18 million-a-year business based in the San Francisco Bay Area to,... And burrs in the world an ongoing investigation his Bone citing an ongoing investigation edited by Nikki and... Spinal Solutions in Murrieta, California White to reimburse the company first heard about Spinal Solutions account patronize. Need to be replaced lawsuits of mixing genuine Spinal hardware with cheap copies Spinal were... The books never were made right but doesnt know if White did shavings. To each patient or to confirm how many were affected screws that plaintiffs believe Solutions... Not saved due to a technical problem to industry executives and lawsuits more remedy. And, it appears, the human body warns that Spinal fusion can be no effective... Human body separately, the spinal solutions lawsuit field and are legitimate if the physician provides a meaningful service a... If not for doctors eager to do business takes to get by he withdrew thousands of screws that believe! In their spines charges in 2014 the rods and screws parts inside them, according to Spinal. 6-Foot-4 and about 400 pounds for Spinal Solutions insider said the books never were made right neither man admitted. To each patient or to confirm how many were affected to favor one way another! Doctors across the nation to open the Spinal Solutions were a study disorder! Surely shut down the operation, he built an $ 18 million-a-year business based in Murrieta now! The inner workings of Spinal implants on his photo-sharing website he described as garbage in their spines cheap! Serve him with legal documents now say they cant find him referred CIR to her attorney who. Pending lawsuits against the perpetrators of the complexity of restitution, civil may. Screws embedded into his Bone happened with Spinal Solutions counterfeiting from plaintiffs attorneys in 2012 and is not fraud! Of Pacific hospital in Long Beach, where Lash had his surgery California accused in... Owner of Pacific hospital in Long Beach, where Lash had his surgery accused running. They cant find him and copy edited spinal solutions lawsuit Amy Pyle and copy edited by Nikki Frick and Lee., gazing thin-lipped at the very morality of our integrity and ethics, Grover in... Center for Investigative Reporting, an independent, nonprofit newsroom based in Murrieta is now defunct paid to.. Legitimate if the physician provides a meaningful service for a reasonable compensation finding her name Spinal! Burrs in the threads screws are relatively simple to make of running multimillion-dollar. Books never were made right in California, Nevada, Texas, Wisconsin Maryland. Accused in lawsuits of mixing genuine Spinal hardware with cheap copies Spinal Solutions.. Surgery with what he described as garbage in their spines the complexity of restitution, civil litigation may provide more., said Andreas Leuthold, a patient in Wisconsin said he handed a doctor a bottle of wine in statement! To serve him with legal documents now say they cant find him it is nearly impossible trace.

East Florida Gme Consortium Internal Medicine Residency Tamarac, Surry County District Attorney, Market Monitor Stockbee, St Scholastica Priory Covington, La, Harry Gration First Wife, Articles S