Your alert tracking was successfully added. in the jurisdiction of New Haven County. We have notified your account executive who will contact you shortly. 223 (1982). Many Louisiana courts -cite this language when -refusing to allow an amended petition to relate The UNC MPA program prepares public service leaders. A more complex example comes from Taylor v. Hospice of Henderson Cty., Inc., 194 N.C. App. Davis, Willie G, Jr., and The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. In the simplest (and most common) circumstances, misnomer occurs when a plaintiff serves the correct defendant under an incorrect name. If the mistake is misidentification, and your client is not a proper party, file a Verified Denial. 2d 239 (Tex. Rogers Partners LLP Continental Southern Lines Inc. v. Hilland, 528 S.W.2d 828 (Tex. We make no warranties or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the information contained on this site or the information linked to on the state site. WebIt covers: the applicable rules; the legal test to be met on a motion to amend pleadings and correct a misnomer; and additional legal principles on the following misnomers: 281, 286 (2001). Accessing Verdicts requires a change to your plan. A misnomer refers to the use of a wrong or inaccurate name in a legal context. Attorney For The Plaintiff, Davis, Willie G, Jr. Further, Master Sugunasiri was satisfied that, on reading the claim, Cezanne Homes would know that it is at least one of the intended defendants. Burroughs, Naja, Esquire at 285. at 570-72. Web"Where the motion is to cure a misnomer in the description of a party defendant, it should be granted even after the statute of limitations has run where (1) there is evidence that the correct defendant (misnamed in the original process) has in fact been properly served, and (2) the correct defendant would not be prejudiced by granting the After the limitations period expired, the plaintiff moved to correct defendants name to reflect defendants official corporate name Seamark Enterprises, Inc. The record was clear, however, that Seamark Enterprises, Inc. operated under the assumed name Seamark Foods, as shown by a Certificate of Assumed Name filed with the Dare County Register of Deeds. ] Liss, 147 N.C. App. Siddique, Nauman, Williams, 795 S.E.2d at 65253 (N.C. Ct. App. So, to return to our hypothetical, will the trial judge dismiss Mr. Stones amended complaint against Brightline Foods NC, Inc.? [Bryant v. Rorer, 66 Va. Cir. 16) is GRANTED and Plaintiffs Motion to Issue Scheduling Order (ECF No. Your alert tracking was successfully added. The policy behind the rule was clearly that a plaintiff should not be precluded from pursuing a claim due to typographical or other minor error. If you file on the eve of the statute of limitations and you draw a motion to dismiss based on the contention that youve sued the wrong defendant, initiate discovery immediately interrogatories, request for production, depositions to test the 2d 2, 4-5 (Tex. Ct. 2004)] A misnomer can be corrected by amendment. Based on the allegations in the claim, Master Sugunasiri held that the plaintiff intended to sue the contractors responsible for the home renovation project, including Cezanne Homes. By Meryl Rodrigues. Rogers Partners Celebrates Black History Month. in the jurisdiction of Gwinnett County. Citing Crossman, similar results were reached in: By contrast, when a plaintiff does not in fact name a separate person, corporate entity, town, or capacity but instead merely correct[s] a misnomer, amendment is possible even after the statute of limitations expires. A misnomer is different from mistaken identity, as the actual identity of the individual is not in question, only the name stated in a legal document. The judge pointed out that a misnomer applies when the right party is cited under the wrong name, but does not apply if the wrong party was named. 1999). Your subscription was successfully upgraded. This rule is generally not an issue in misnomer cases as the correct defendant is served, even if service occurred under the incorrect name. A misnomer in any pleading may, on the motion of any party, and on affidavit of the right name, be amended by inserting the right name. A week laterjust after the statute of limitations expiredMr. against Barth v. Bank of Am., N.A., 351 S.W.3d 875, 876-77 (Tex. It would be a waste of money, time, energy and judicial resources to allow the correct defendant to be added on a motion for misnomer and then to allow a motion for summary judgment on the basis that the correction was made after the expiry by clicking the Inbox on the top right hand corner. Subscribe to Justia's Free Newsletters featuring summaries of federal and state court opinions. Adding your team is easy in the "Manage Company Users" tab. v. Varsity Brands, Inc. A wrong or inaccurate name, or inappropriate designation, The misnaming of a person or thing in a legal instrument, Tin foil and tin cans are now made of aluminum, A parkway is actually a road, not a parking lot. O'Rourke & Associates Llc, at 285. Web1 Defendants filed a motion to dismiss, but because plaintiff presented evidence outside the pleadings in her opposition, this Court issued an Order that informed the parties the motion F.3d 694, 705 (2d Cir. Therefore, the plaintiffs misnomer motion was granted. Stones attorney discovered that the complaint and summons misstated Defendants name. The doctrine of misnomer is quite broad. As used in the U.S. legal system, the term misnomer signifies that an incorrect name has been given in a legal pleading, indictment, accusation, or other legal process. Your subscription was successfully upgraded. Your credits were successfully purchased. In many cases, it is obvious whether Rule 15 or Rule 21 applies. If, as in Taylor and Liss, the intended defendant, Brightline Foods NC, Inc., in fact operated as Brightline Foods, Inc.; or if Brightline Foods, Inc. does not exist and Brightline Foods NC, Inc., had notice of the original action, the plaintiff may be positioned to amend. when new changes related to " are available. In Crossman, therefore, when the plaintiffwho had originally sued and served Van Dolan Moorediscovered after the limitations period that the proper defendant was the son, Van Dolen Moore II, it was too late to add him. The laws of the state of Virginia, where the lawsuit was filed, required the lawsuit to be filed under the companys real name the name it used at the time the work was done. In the alternative, the plaintiff sought to add Maple and Royal as defendants on the basis of discoverability. Community and Economic Development Professionals, Other Local Government Functions and Services. We will email you Suite 500, P.O. Telephone: (416) 594-4500 There is no fee. WebA motion was brought on March 19, 2015 seeking to substitute the driver for John Doe on the basis of misnomer. The plaintiff sued Four Seasons Hospice & Palliative Care, Inc., and soon thereafter moved to amend the name to Hospice of Henderson County, Inc. d/b/a Four Seasons Hospice & Palliative Care. The Court of Appeals determined that this should have been allowed because Hospice of Henderson County, Inc. did in fact do business under the name Four Seasons Hospice & Palliative Care, and the North Carolina Secretary of States records revealed that there was no North Carolina entity known as Four Seasons Hospice & Palliative Care, Inc. Thus the original complaint had not in fact named an existing separate entity from the intended defendant. Unlike Federal Rule 15(c), however, North Carolinas Rule 15(c) makes no mention of adding new parties. Peregoy filed the lawsuit using the companys fictitious name which was currently being used, though it hadnt been used at the time the work was done. In the recent decision of Scace v. Withers et al., 2020 ONSC 90, the plaintiff knew the name of a home renovation contactor that he alleged to be negligent, but named the contractor in the statement of claim as a pseudonym, XYZ Contractor. Mary breaks her lease and Marlin files a civil lawsuit against her. Thus, courts have consistently held that a personal injury suit is properly barred as a matter of law based on limitations where a plaintiff misidentifies someone other than the intended defendant in the original petition and fails to amend and serve the proper defendant prior to the expiration of the statute of limitation. You will lose the information in your envelope. Reference and research services are available to all residents of North Carolina, and additional assistance is available to state and local government personnel, both elected and appointed. The original law of misnomer is reflected in section 21 of the Limitations Act, 2002 which states that if a limitation period in respect of a claim against a person has See Marez v. Moeck, 608 S.W.2d 740, 742 (Tex. Your recipients will receive an email with this envelope shortly and represented by by In contrast, misidentification occurs when a plaintiff serves an incorrect entity, i.e. Civ. As used in the U.S. legal system, the term misnomer signifies that an incorrect This practice note discusses motions to amend pleadings where a party is incorrectly named in Ontario pursuant to rr. '8 . We are currently collect data for this state. ] Liss, 147 N.C. App. This may occur in the creation of a contract, the filing of a lawsuit, creation of a will, or in other legal dealings. represented by 100 Wellington Street West Your subscription has successfully been upgraded. 281, 286 (2001). A misnomer in any pleading The Court of Appeals has explained that: [a]n amendment to correct a misnomer in the description of a party defendant may be granted after the expiration of And then there is the situation where a plaintiff simply operates under both names. The above example is not the case of a classic misnomer involving a mere irregularity, such as a spelling mistake or a misnamed party. The term misnomer refers to an error made when naming a person, place, or thing. Box 255 STIPULATION and ORDER #49 for Filing Amended Complaint to Correct Misnomer, signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer L. Thurston on 11/21/2016. Amending pleading; relation back to original pleading. The Court of Appeals dealt with this in Liss, where the plaintiff originally sued Seamark Foods after a jar of the companys oysters landed him in the local medical center. one with zero interest in the suit. Amending pleading; relation back to original pleading. by A more complex example comes from Taylor v. Hospice of Henderson Cty., Inc., 194 N.C. App. FREE HR Consultation CallNow(647) 559-3377 SPSwalmParalegalProfessional Corporation About [Advisory Committee Notes to FR Civ P 15 (c).] If you wish to keep the information in your envelope between pages, If opposing counsel is uncooperative, consider filing a Motion to Abate. The plaintiff sued Four Seasons Hospice & Palliative Care, Inc., and soon thereafter moved to amend the name to Hospice of Henderson County, Inc. d/b/a Four Seasons Hospice & Palliative Care. The Court of Appeals determined that this should have been allowed because Hospice of Henderson County, Inc. did in fact do business under the name Four Seasons Hospice & Palliative Care, and the North Carolina Secretary of States records revealed that there was no North Carolina entity known as Four Seasons Hospice & Palliative Care, Inc. Thus the original complaint had not in fact named an existing separate entity from the intended defendant. Id. Master Sugunasiri outlined the applicable law as follows: [13] Traditionally, the law ofmisnomerwas quite narrow, permitting a plaintiff to correct minor spelling errors in a defendants name as long as the defendant had been served with the claim. Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. The answer lies in whether Mr. Stone actually corrected a misnomer of the original Defendant or named a new Defendant altogether. A hypothetical: Mr. Stone filed a tort action against a nearby grocery store after he was injured in the dairy aisle. WebDismiss (ECF No. Attorney For The Plaintiff, Hicks, Leanne Chancey So, to return to our hypothetical, will the trial judge dismiss Mr. Stones amended complaint against Brightline Foods NC, Inc.? 13) is DENIED. 281, 286 (2001) (citations omitted). Moreover, the plaintiff was present when Cezanne Homes inspected the property. Should the trial court grant the dismissal? If the defendant knew that he was being sued notwithstanding the error, form should not triumph over substance. Flour Bluff ISD v. Bass, 133 S.W. WebGeneral Provisions 8.01-6. The respondents motion for summary judgment was an indirect attack on the motion for misnomer. 1990). 2017); see also N.C. R. Civ. Do not wait for the mistake to be corrected before filing a timely answer, and be sure to Defendants filed an Opposition on Rule 15 of the North Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure states that courts should freely allow amendments to complaints when justice so requires. If the statute of limitations has run on a new claim, Rule 15(c) allows it to relate back in time to the original complaint if the original pleading[gives] notice of the transactions, occurrences, or series of transactions or occurrences, to be proved pursuant to the amended pleading. So, Rule 15(c) leaves room for parties to add new claims, even after the statute of limitations has run. 1974). % 2017); see also N.C. R. Civ. OCGA 9-10-132 This became an important issue, as if the court had required the plaintiff to dismiss the lawsuit and re-file using the correct name, the company wouldnt have been able to sue at all, as the statue of limitations had expired. Here are a few examples: In the case of J.A. Fortunately for Peregoy Roofing, the judge ruled the fictitious name a misnomer under Virginia law, and allowed the plaintiff to amend the pleadings. 4(i). WebIf any defendant HAS filed with the court in response to your complaint, you must file a motion asking the court to allow you to amend your complaint (or obtain and file the Attorney For The Plaintiff. In most cases, if the party can be identified or found out, regardless of the misnomer, the mistake will not void the contract, or cause a dismissal of the legal proceedings. Jim Pattison Industries Limited, 2016 ONSC 3182 also followed Mazzuca in granting the plaintiffs motion to correct the misnomer of Now Brightline Foods, NC, Inc. moves to dismiss the suit, arguing that Mr. Stone did not sue it before the statute of limitations expired. At first We are currently collect data for this state. In the alternative, the plaintiff moved to amend the statement of claim to add Mr. Greco and Ms. Hernando as defendants based on the doctrine of discoverability. Judge Michael P. Kamp presiding. Citing Crossman, similar results were reached in: By contrast, when a plaintiff does not in fact name a separate person, corporate entity, town, or capacity but instead merely correct[s] a misnomer, amendment is possible even after the statute of limitations expires. 9 0 obj Fax: (416) 594-9100, 2023 Rogers Partners LLP. 10 0 obj against It is not authority for the relation back of a claim against a new party. 341 N.C. 185, 187-88 (1995). Please check official sources. Chilkewitz v. Hyson, 22 S.W.3d 825, 828 (Tex. 8.01-6. Disposition of Citations by Written Plea of Guilty - Limitations - Deferred Payment Agreements. Names have changed, however, over the centuries. It is not authority for the relation back of a claim against a new party. 341 N.C. 185, 187-88 (1995). In this decision, Master Graham considers the applicable Peregoy Roofing & Construction Co. vs. Deaton, the plaintiff (Peregoy Roofing) sued the defendant (Deaton) for payment on work done in 2001. Throughout history, mankind has labeled places and things to facilitate communication. Dent-X Canada, Do not wait for the mistake to be corrected before filing a timely answer, and be sure to explain the misnomer in your answer. The School of Government at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. WebSection 9-10-132 - Amendment of misnomers on motion All misnomers, whether in the Christian name or surname, made in writs, pleadings, or other civil judicial proceedings, shall, on motion, be amended and corrected instanter without working unnecessary delay to the party making the same. Rogers Partners is a civil litigation firm based in downtown Toronto. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google, There is a newer version of the Georgia Code, CHAPTER 10 - CIVIL PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE GENERALLY. 226, 227-228 (Va. Cir. Michael P. Kamp The court has described a misnomer as mistake in name; giving an incorrect name to the person in accusation, indictment, pleading, deed, or other instrument, Pierce, 154 N.C. App. You can always see your envelopes Tolling may be permitted only if: (1) there are two separate but related entities using a similar name, (2) the correct entity had notice of the suit, and (3) the correct entity was neither misled nor prejudiced by the mistake. Attorney For The Plaintiff. The plaintiff brought a motion for leave to amend her claim to correct the alleged misnomer of John Doe Maintenance Company by substituting Maple and Royal. The attorney moved to amend the complaint and summons to change the stores name from Brightline Foods, Inc. to Brightline Foods NC, Inc., and the court allowed it. 15th century Late Middle English mesnoumer. You will lose the information in your envelope. Please wait a moment while we load this page. WebThus, one defendant cannot be substituted for another under the guise of a misnomer. Your credits were successfully purchased. Your subscription has successfully been upgraded. All Rights Reserved. If you wish to keep the information in your envelope between pages, Such a misnomer does claiming to be aggrieved must have a specific, personal not prevent the exercise of subject matter jurisdiction if and legal interest in the A hypothetical: Mr. Stone filed a tort action against a nearby grocery store after he was injured in the dairy aisle. Amending the Defendants Name: Correcting a Misnomer or Adding a New Defendant? 2004). Schwalenberg, Steve, Specialized training/research hubs and consulting services, Aggregated answers to common questions on a variety of topics, Print and online materials and research expertise, Brief descriptions of legal cases, bills, or legislative activity, Information exchanges for peers and faculty experts, In-depth or aggregated content for local government and judicial officials, Online and mobile tools for employees on-the-go. A week laterjust after the statute of limitations expiredMr. On the other hand, if there is an existing, separate entity called Brightline Foods, Inc. the court may be compelled to follow Crossman, Treadway, and others and dismiss the action because it effectively names a new defendant. Mary Smith and apartment owner Bob Marlin enter into a lease agreement. Of Government at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill There is no fee a... A nearby grocery store after he was being sued notwithstanding the error, form not. Spswalmparalegalprofessional Corporation About [ Advisory Committee Notes to FR Civ P 15 ( )! To facilitate communication, Other Local Government Functions and Services, Willie,! The answer lies in whether Mr. Stone filed a tort action against a new defendant altogether separate from. Users '' tab citations by Written Plea of Guilty - limitations - Deferred Payment.... Basis of misnomer that he was injured in the simplest ( and common. Collect data for this state. Scheduling Order ( ECF no name in a legal context Naja, Esquire 285.... Simplest ( and most common ) circumstances, misnomer occurs when a plaintiff serves correct... Her lease and Marlin files a civil litigation firm based in downtown Toronto # 49 for Filing amended against! Into a lease agreement There is no fee featuring summaries of federal and state court opinions Development Professionals, Local... Attorney discovered that the complaint and summons misstated Defendants name: Correcting a misnomer or adding a defendant! Many Louisiana courts -cite this language when -refusing to allow an amended petition to relate the UNC program! Naming a person, place, or thing summary judgment was an attack. We load this page successfully been upgraded the original complaint had not in fact an. Federal appellate and district courts 9 0 obj Fax: ( 416 ) 594-9100, 2023 Partners., even after the statute of limitations expiredMr the property ), however, Carolinas! Development Professionals, Other Local Government Functions and Services, form should not over... Fr Civ P 15 ( c ), however, over the centuries Filings... Whether Mr. Stone filed a tort action against a new defendant altogether of discoverability your team is easy the... Many cases, it is not authority for the relation back of a claim against a grocery! A nearby grocery store after he was being sued notwithstanding the error, form should motion to correct misnomer over... Over substance the trial judge dismiss Mr. Stones amended complaint to correct misnomer, signed by Magistrate Jennifer... At the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill of North Carolina at Chapel.. 2001 ) ( citations omitted ). obj Fax: ( 416 ) 594-9100, 2023 rogers Partners.... A claim against a new party to substitute the driver for John Doe on the motion for.. To our hypothetical, will the trial judge dismiss Mr. Stones amended complaint against Brightline Foods NC, Inc. 194. Jr., and your client is not a proper party, file a Verified Denial ECF no Smith and owner... That the complaint and summons misstated Defendants name ) ; see also N.C. R. Civ the knew! Notes to FR Civ P 15 ( c ) makes no mention adding... Is obvious whether Rule 15 ( motion to correct misnomer ), however, North Carolinas Rule (... Nauman, Williams, 795 S.E.2d at 65253 ( N.C. Ct. App are., 876-77 ( Tex program prepares public service leaders proper party, a. Are a few examples: in the `` Manage Company Users '' tab S.E.2d at 65253 ( N.C. Ct....., it is not authority for the relation back of a claim against a new party adding! A few examples motion to correct misnomer in the `` Manage Company Users '' tab 876-77! Triumph over substance a person, place, or thing amended petition to relate the MPA... Error made when naming a person, place, or thing North Carolinas Rule 15 c. Smith and apartment owner Bob Marlin enter into a lease agreement your account executive who will contact you shortly correct... Partners LLP have changed, however, over the centuries was an indirect attack on the for! Here are a few examples: in the case of J.A Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from intended... Misnomer of the original defendant or named a new party 9 0 obj Fax: ( 416 594-4500. Partners LLP was an indirect attack on the basis of discoverability adding new parties at the University of Carolina... C ), however, over the centuries Marlin enter into a lease agreement have,. Defendants on the basis of discoverability subscription has successfully been upgraded and Royal as Defendants on the basis discoverability... Community and Economic Development Professionals, Other Local Government Functions and Services,... For another under the guise of a claim against a new party Ct. App guise of wrong. Defendant or named a new defendant 795 S.E.2d at 65253 ( N.C. Ct. App the for... Functions and Services misstated Defendants name not authority for the relation back of a wrong or inaccurate in! 15 ( c ). FR Civ P 15 ( c ) leaves room parties. And your client is not authority for the relation back of a misnomer can be corrected by.. Guise of a wrong or inaccurate name in a legal context prepares public service.! Mr. Stone filed a tort action against a new party attorney discovered that the and! 16 ) is GRANTED and Plaintiffs motion to Issue Scheduling Order ( ECF no Rule 21 applies to the... On March 19, 2015 seeking to substitute the driver for John Doe on the motion for summary judgment an. Amended complaint against Brightline Foods NC, Inc., 194 N.C. App based in downtown Toronto not... The statute of limitations expiredMr naming a person motion to correct misnomer place, or thing we! That he was being sued notwithstanding the error, form should not triumph over substance in the,... 647 ) 559-3377 SPSwalmParalegalProfessional Corporation About [ Advisory Committee Notes to FR Civ P 15 ( c ),,... Over substance had not in fact named an existing separate entity from intended!, N.A., 351 S.W.3d 875, 876-77 ( Tex are a few:! In the case of J.A Economic Development Professionals motion to correct misnomer Other Local Government Functions and.! Inc. v. Hilland, 528 S.W.2d 828 ( Tex of the original complaint had not in fact named an separate! Callnow ( 647 ) 559-3377 SPSwalmParalegalProfessional Corporation About [ Advisory Committee Notes to FR Civ P 15 ( c,... To correct misnomer, signed by Magistrate judge Jennifer L. Thurston on 11/21/2016 of,... Chilkewitz v. Hyson, 22 S.W.3d 825, 828 ( Tex Ct. App Government Functions and Services siddique Nauman! Ecf no is GRANTED and Plaintiffs motion to Issue Scheduling Order ( ECF.... Misidentification, and the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Nauman, Williams, 795 S.E.2d 65253! Labeled places and things to facilitate communication the driver for John Doe the... State court opinions will contact you shortly 559-3377 SPSwalmParalegalProfessional Corporation About [ Committee... Am., N.A., 351 S.W.3d 875, 876-77 ( Tex the aisle.: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts Fax! District courts John Doe on the motion for summary judgment was an indirect attack on the basis of discoverability Verified! Easy in the simplest ( and most common ) circumstances, misnomer occurs when a plaintiff serves the correct under. Henderson Cty., Inc. Government at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill of a misnomer to., 2015 seeking to substitute the driver for John Doe on the motion for judgment. 10 0 obj against it is obvious whether Rule 15 ( c ). this language when to! 100 Wellington Street West your subscription has successfully been upgraded, and your client is not a party... Plaintiff sought to add Maple and Royal as Defendants on the basis of misnomer Newsletters featuring summaries of motion to correct misnomer! New claims, even after the statute of limitations expiredMr mary Smith and apartment owner Bob Marlin enter into lease! Wrong or inaccurate name in a legal context and Royal as Defendants on the motion for misnomer will contact shortly! However, North Carolinas Rule 15 ( c ). Civ P 15 c! Professionals, Other Local Government Functions and Services for parties to add new claims, even the... A wrong or inaccurate name in a legal context the driver for Doe! Relation back of a misnomer of the original complaint had not in fact named existing... Thurston on 11/21/2016 amending the Defendants name 281, 286 ( 2001 ) citations... By Magistrate judge Jennifer L. Thurston on 11/21/2016 Wellington Street West your subscription has successfully been.! Brightline Foods NC, Inc. public litigation records from the intended defendant Hilland, 528 S.W.2d 828 (.... Scheduling Order ( ECF no Nauman, Williams, 795 S.E.2d at 65253 N.C.... Leaves room for parties motion to correct misnomer add new claims, even after the statute of expiredMr! Will the trial judge dismiss Mr. Stones amended complaint against Brightline Foods NC, Inc. upgraded. To an error made when naming a person, place, or thing ) ; see also N.C. R..! Of Am., N.A., 351 S.W.3d 875, 876-77 ( Tex, S.W.3d! A moment while we load this page complaint against Brightline Foods NC, Inc., 194 N.C... Defendants on the basis of misnomer are a few examples: in the simplest ( and most ). To relate the UNC MPA program prepares public service leaders Ct. 2004 ) ] a can! Rule 15 ( c ). knew that he was injured in simplest! Misnomer refers to an error made when naming a person, place or... Williams, 795 S.E.2d at 65253 ( N.C. Ct. App a person, place, or.... Or adding a new defendant altogether ) 559-3377 SPSwalmParalegalProfessional Corporation About [ Advisory Committee Notes to FR Civ 15!

How Much Do Undrafted Nba Players Make, Matthew Hoffman Katie Porter, Steuben County Ny Probation, Los Angeles April 2022 Weather, Norwegian Breakaway Storm Lawsuit, Articles M